A sample mean and a member of that sample share an observation. Do not assume they are independent merely because they are written with different symbols.
Rewrite before using variance rules
Let \(X_1,X_2,X_3\) be independent observations from \(N(\mu,\sigma^2)\), and let \(\overline{X}=\dfrac{X_1+X_2+X_3}{3}\). Then \[\overline{X}-X_1=\frac{-2X_1+X_2+X_3}{3}.\] Hence its mean is zero and its variance is \(\dfrac{(4+1+1)\sigma^2}{9}=\dfrac{2\sigma^2}{3}\). It is exactly normal.
| Reasoning | Result |
|---|---|
| Incorrectly treat \(\overline{X}\) and \(X_1\) as independent | \(\dfrac{\sigma^2}{3}+\sigma^2=\dfrac{4\sigma^2}{3}\): invalid |
| Collect coefficients of the independent observations first | \(\overline{X}-X_1\sim N\left(0,\dfrac{2\sigma^2}{3}\right)\) |
Bridge the idea
Now replace \(X_1\) by a new independent observation \(X_4\) from the same population. The samples no longer overlap, so \(\operatorname{Var}(\overline{X}-X_4)=\dfrac{4\sigma^2}{3}\). The different answer comes from the model, not a changed formula.
Exam wording: “The quantities share an observation, so independence cannot be assumed. Express the difference in terms of the original independent observations before calculating its variance.”
Create a free account to practise similar questions.
Need help? Join our JC Math tuition classes.
Learn more