Three independently selected objects and one object counted three times are different random models. Read what is being repeated before choosing the variance.
| Situation | Random variable | Variance |
|---|---|---|
| Three independent observations, each with variance \(\sigma^2\) | \(X_1+X_2+X_3\) | \(3\sigma^2\) |
| Three times one observed value | \(3X\) | \(9\sigma^2\) |
Both have mean \(3\mu\). If the individual observations are normal and independent, their sum is normal. Multiplying a single normal variable by 3 also preserves normality, but scales its variance by \(3^2\).
Bridge the idea
A package contains three independently selected bottles. Compare its total liquid volume with a machine reading that is three times the volume of one bottle. The package uses three random observations; the reading repeatedly uses the same observation.
Write the variables first: \(T=X_1+X_2+X_3\) versus \(R=3X\). Then state independence only for the distinct bottle volumes when needed. You cannot make three copies of \(X\) independent by assigning them different labels.
Exam wording: “The volumes of the three independently selected bottles are assumed independent, so the total variance is the sum of their individual variances.”
Create a free account to practise similar questions.
Need help? Join our JC Math tuition classes.
Learn more