Random Selection, Independence and Bias

Random Selection, Independence and Bias

Junior College 2
TGM Original Questions

Before discussing normality or sample size, identify the population and how observations were selected. A large collection of convenient observations may still give biased information about the target population.

ConditionWhat to check
Random selectionThe selection mechanism should not systematically favour a particular part of the population.
Common populationObservations should concern the same population and comparable conditions for the proposed model.
IndependenceOne observation should not systematically determine another. Repeated measurements on the same person may be dependent.

Bridge the idea

A school wants the mean journey time of all its students. It surveys 500 students who arrive before 7 a.m. Is the large sample enough? No: later arrivals are excluded, so the sampling method may systematically misrepresent the target population. Increasing the same biased sample does not fix the selection problem.

A random sample and independent observations address different issues. Sampling without replacement from a finite population is not exactly independent; independence may be a reasonable approximation when the sample is a small proportion of that population.

Exam wording: “Assume the observations form an independent random sample from the stated population.” If a flaw is evident, name it in context: “Students arriving later are excluded, so the sample may be biased.” Normality is a separate distribution question.

Similar questions are unavailable for this question.

Need help? Join our JC Math tuition classes.

Learn more