Correlation and a Causal Explanation

Correlation and a Causal Explanation

Junior College 2
TGM Original Questions

A strong correlation describes an association in the data. It does not, by itself, show that changing one variable causes the other to change. This is a different judgement from deciding whether a regression prediction is useful.

Bridge the explanation

Sales of cold drinks and numbers of swimmers are positively correlated. A plausible third factor is hot weather: it can increase both quantities. Buying more cold drinks has not thereby been shown to cause more people to swim.

StatementWhat the data support
“Higher cold-drink sales tend to accompany more swimmers.”An association, if the observed data support it.
“Increasing cold-drink sales causes more people to swim.”A causal claim that correlation alone does not establish.
“The association can help a prediction.”Possibly, if the fitted model is suitable and the prediction conditions are comparable.

Give a contextual alternative explanation, such as a shared influence, reverse direction, or how the observations were selected. Do not stop at the slogan “correlation is not causation”; explain why the proposed causal reading is unsupported here.

Exam wording: “The correlation alone does not establish causation. Hot weather may increase both cold-drink sales and the number of swimmers, producing the observed association.” Prediction reliability and causation answer different questions.

Similar questions are unavailable for this question.

Need help? Join our JC Math tuition classes.

Learn more