Choosing a Regression Line and Controlled Calibration

Choosing a Regression Line and Controlled Calibration

Junior College 2
TGM Original Questions

Choose a regression direction from what is being predicted and how the data were obtained. The labels x and y do not tell you whether an input was controlled.

ContextAppropriate reasoning
Two ordinary measured variables; predict y from xUse the regression of y on x.
Two ordinary measured variables; predict x from yUse the regression of x on y; rearranging the y-on-x line generally gives a different fit.
Experimenter controls x and observes response yFit response y on controlled input x. A justified target-response calculation can solve this same response model for x.

Bridge the idea

Height and mass are both measured. To estimate height from mass, use height on mass. In a different experiment, an operator sets a heater input and measures temperature. Fit temperature on the controlled heater input; solving that calibration model for a desired temperature can be appropriate.

For a controlled calibration \(y=12+3x\), a desired response \(y=30\) gives \(x=6\), subject to the fitted range and unchanged experimental conditions. This inversion uses the controlled response model; it does not claim to produce the reverse least-squares line for two ordinary measured variables.

Exam wording: “Use response on the controlled input because the input was fixed by the experimenter.” For ordinary measured pairs: “Use the variable to be estimated regressed on the given variable.” Check reliability separately.

Need help? Join our JC Math tuition classes.

Learn more