Choosing a method and checking

Choosing a method and checking

Secondary 2

Elimination, substitution and the graphical method all find the same solution. Elimination and substitution are exact; the graphical method also shows the two lines but usually gives an estimate. Choose the method that makes the working shortest.

Why both algebraic methods work: each turns two equations in two unknowns into one equation in one unknown. Elimination does it by adding or subtracting equations; substitution does it by replacing one unknown with an equal expression.

What the equations look likeA good choiceReason
one unknown is already the subject, as in \(y=7x-2\)substitutionthe expression is ready to substitute
an unknown has coefficient \(1\) or \(-1\)substitution or eliminationit is easy to make it the subject
one unknown has the same or opposite coefficientseliminationadd or subtract straight away
all coefficients are larger numberselimination after multiplyingsubstitution would bring in fractions
a graph is asked for, or an estimate is enoughgraphical methodthe intersection gives the solution

Method

  1. Look at the coefficients and decide which method fits, using the table.
  2. Solve, showing each step.
  3. Check the pair in both original equations, not in a rearranged or multiplied version.

Example

Solve \(4x+y=5\) \((1)\) and \(7x-3y=23\) \((2)\). No unknown is the subject, but \(y\) has coefficient \(1\) in \((1)\), so both methods are short. Compare them.

Substitution: from \((1)\), \(y=5-4x\).

\(\begin{aligned} 7x-3(5-4x)&=23 \\ 19x-15&=23 \\ x&=2 \end{aligned}\)

Elimination: \((1)\times3\) gives \(12x+3y=15\).

\(\begin{aligned} (12x+3y)+(7x-3y)&=15+23 \\ 19x&=38 \\ x&=2 \end{aligned}\)

Both give \(x=2\); then \(y=5-4(2)=-3\). Check: in \((1)\), \(4(2)+(-3)=5\); in \((2)\), \(7(2)-3(-3)=14+9=23\).

Why check both: the pair \((5,4)\) satisfies \((2)\), because \(7(5)-3(4)=23\), but not \((1)\), because \(4(5)+4=24\ne5\). Checking only one equation would let a wrong answer pass.

Need help? Join our E-Maths tuition for O-Level success.

Learn more